Showing posts with label Rights. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Rights. Show all posts
Tuesday, May 14, 2013
Ninth Amendment And What It Means To Be A Free People
Madison addressing the House of Representatives in 1789:
"It has been objected also against a Bill of Rights, that, by enumerating particular exceptions to the grant of power, it would disparage those rights which were not placed in that enumeration; and it might follow by implication, that those rights which were not singled out, were intended to be assigned into the hands of the General Government, and were consequently insecure. This is one of the most plausible arguments I have ever heard against the admission of a bill of rights into this system; but, I conceive, that it may be guarded against."
This led to the Ninth amendment with in the Bill of Rights:
"The enumeration in the Constitution, of certain rights, shall not be construed to deny or disparage others retained by the people."
These are the kinds of words Madison sought to have written into democracy. He wanted to ensure that freedom was written into it in a way that would resist the efforts to undermine it. This amendment often ignored by many is one of the most significant rights we have. It says that we have all of those rights that some would have attempted to deny us just because they were not overtly ratified within the Bill of Rights. What list of rights could ever ensure our freedom with out demanding that we have all the ones it doesn't mention?
It is also one of my most cherished rights, because of what it reveals about freedom in our democracy. It is utterly unworkable as an amendment, if you are bent on reducing our rights to some simple meaning. Madison clearly intended for the Ninth amendment to be a doorway through which all of our freedoms and liberties, that weren't explicitly included, would gain entrance into the Bill of Rights. He was placing responsibility directly on us within this amendment. Our rights demand that we work at them to understand them. Madison was telling us that no paper was going to remove that responsibility from us. A responsibility that would be a heavy burden upon us all. Over the course of American history many have given their lives to it. Under this right we have the right to privacy and many others that are all implicit, but born on the backs of those who continue to fight for them. The whole Constitution is written like this, with loosely constructed language or areas where it simply requires us to determine what these implicit rights will mean. It places the burden of giving shape to democracy on the citizens that it ultimately rests upon.
The only way the Supreme Court is going to be able to make a determination is by trying to figure out what the force of the principles behind all of our rights is. This is difficult because behind all of those rights is a principle among others of equality before the law. We have seen even the founders fail to fulfill the promise of that principle. Slavery wasn't abolished until the Civil War. So when we ask what the Constitution means we have to ask what the force of its principles are, even when we realize that the very same founders who gave us these words and their inspiration were people who fell short of them. They are not alone. All of us as citizens in our democracy striving towards the force of those principles have fallen short. Our responsibility to uphold equality before the law demands thats we actively engage it as citizens rather than simply receive it as subjects.
Even today gay and lesbian couples are denied equality before the law. Whatever we may think marriage means, it is irrelevant in the face of our responsibility as a citizen and as a free people. Equality before the law doesn't care what we may think marriage means. As long as It is an institution that is sanctioned by our democracy, it demands that everyone have an equal opportunity in principle to be able to have access to it.
At this point in history to fall short of this means that when it was our turn to expand equality under the law we failed. The standard that falls upon the founders who secured our freedom is different than the one we should labor under. The standard that falls upon those who fought for civil rights is different then the one we should labor under. We shouldn't expect more of ourselves then what these men and women had done, we should expect that we attempt to do as much as they had done! When they were given the challenge to expand our equality they did not shrug. They attempted to move us forward and we owe our future generations as much.
It is the nature of democracy that each generation must remake its laws and interpret the ones it has received, that it write its democracy anew. This is what it means to be a free people. It is the responsibility of every American that when democracy is written by our generation that its words are equality before the law. This is what drove the founders to free a nation, this is what freed the slaves, and this is what brought women the right to vote. This responsibility is what is most sacred in our ties to that history. Isn't this is who we are and what it means to be a free people?
Wednesday, May 8, 2013
Libertarian mugged by reality
Irving Kristol has been infamously credited with having been an intellectual father of Neoconservatism. He said that he was a "liberal who had been mugged by reality". Neoconservatism has received a thorough thrashing from reality between the recent turn of the century and the eight years that have followed. I'm not really interested in being critical of Irving Kristol, or the rapidly shrinking Neoconservative wing of the Republican party. It is not my intention to address them or their views here, I might save that for another time. I was just struck by the same sense of having been "mugged" by reality. Strangely I seem to be a libertarian who has been mugged by reality. I often wondered as a high school student how a free people could ever have agreed to Theodore Roosevelt's efforts to increase the size of government and bust up monopolies. If free enterprise can be undercut, then the rest of our liberties were also being placed in peril. I hope you will forgive the "slippery slope" argument here, which is of course a piece of foolishness despite any partisan affiliation it changes. Nuance and complexity may have been lost on me… I was at least in high school when I used this argument. The complex historical realities behind this move were also lost on me. What would they matter anyway to my youth, in the face of our liberties. Do we not live in the land where Patrick Henry helped give birth to a nation with courageous words. "Give me liberty or give me death" are still words that stir me deeply. Back then they were written into my heart as a seal before all else. Any history lesson raising complex problems would have been pointless from the ideological purity I brought to an issue. Pragmatism was an American virtue that I failed to appreciate at the time. Which is disappointing, because its probably the quiet backbone that built an American century. That century was a difficult one that cannot simply be painted over, and yet it was often prosperous and forward in its trajectory on some of the issues it faced. It saw women's suffrage, the voting rights act, and a number of landmark changes for the better. Regardless of how complex all of that may be, pragmatism when it has taken a long view was what made America work. We were spared the parade of "isms" that turned Europe into a slaughter, in part because of the sound direction of pragmatism and compromise, as well as the distance we had from the crisis in Europe. It also played a role in driving innovation and enterprise during that century. It was the kind of pragmatism that saw busting up monopolies integral to the creation of a middle class as an engine behind that economy. Where is that pragmatism today? Prosperity devolving under company towns in the hands of a few hoards that could easily pressure the prices for goods and labor couldn't unleash the kind of American strength we saw in that century. The idea behind busting up the monopolies was one of strength gained in promoting a broad prosperous market. What relationship does any of this have to our liberties?
I said that I was a libertarian that had been mugged by reality. I want our rights as individuals to allow us to chart our own course with out the interference of governments. I want to cultivate the notion that liberty is our right despite what others may legislate. I want to promote private spaces that allow for us to find the most efficient means to build stable and flexible communities together. It has often been said that our liberties begin and end where one person's fist meets another's face. Isn't that exactly what has been forgotten about our liberties. What is inalienable within a right flows directly from the relationship of freedom they foster between us and other rights. If they are sacrificed to the degree that they come into contact with someone else's liberties, then they are without any meaning when understood independently of each other. Our liberties don't exist for us as a property of our nature as individuals in a vacuum, but as a relationship of freedom between each of us.
Understanding the deeper relationship between our liberties, and how they operate brings me to another point. This misunderstanding has dangerously undercut the ability of our liberties to function at all as a relationship of freedom between us. We live in a global world where our collective relationships with each other come into contact with those liberties between us in an intimate way. A pragmatic understanding is desperately needed to protect those liberties as relationships caught up within reality. If I pretend that the money I have represents some fixed economic quantity of value, and that it means something that is independent of my economic relationship to you, then I am likely to be gravely disappointed by my liberties regarding economic property. What could possibly go wrong? We have watched as this liberty washed away into something completely unstable, in the wake of subprime mortgages and derivatives that were sold between banks that also held onto savings… at least for a short while they held onto savings… until those banks started collapsing. Moralizing about banks or homeowners or bailouts won't bring that liberty back. Even if your money wasn't in those banks that doesn't mean you get to escape the economic collapse that follows. It doesn't mean that your property is protected. Your fist can't bring injury upon their faces without legal consequence, but the diseases your neighbor acquires after they lose their job and health benefits could kill you. The law won't protect you against that, your health and the value of your property aren't protected. Poverty has many meanings besides the economic one, and all of them are relevant. We have watched as our freedoms have been brought closer to destruction, after a failure to recognize their global reality. "If you do not share your wealth with the poor, they will share their poverty." The reality of that cannot be moralized away by appeals to personal accountability. If a poverty of democracy allows a people to become disenfranchised, and if poverty allows education to become a scarce resource then it affects my liberty. If poverty in other countries leads to poor sewage and limits access to clean water, if poverty allows disease to spread, if poverty allows these places to collapse further into economic failure and the inevitable failure of the state that follows, and that poverty allows terrorism to find a better audience then it affects my liberty. If poverty allows for environmental devastation, and nuclear or chemical waste that pollutes our environment then it affects my liberty. If poverty shows up at the emergency ward and can't pay, If poverty provides no shelter for them or for us from them then it affects my liberty. If poverty allows for the whole globe to fall into economic collapse or international wars like we saw in the last century, as they play out in a world where distances between places are growing smaller…what remains of the freedom that our liberties were meant to protect. If each of us as individuals ignore the impoverished areas of the world, and here at home, we place all of our liberties and their ability to function within jeopardy. Yes I am a libertarian who has been mugged by reality. Pragmatism demands that I understand that my liberties are inextricably bound to those around me, rather than appealing to ideas about personal accountability as if such legal distinctions could protect my liberties in any functional meaningful way.
Understanding the deeper relationship between our liberties, and how they operate brings me to another point. This misunderstanding has dangerously undercut the ability of our liberties to function at all as a relationship of freedom between us. We live in a global world where our collective relationships with each other come into contact with those liberties between us in an intimate way. A pragmatic understanding is desperately needed to protect those liberties as relationships caught up within reality. If I pretend that the money I have represents some fixed economic quantity of value, and that it means something that is independent of my economic relationship to you, then I am likely to be gravely disappointed by my liberties regarding economic property. What could possibly go wrong? We have watched as this liberty washed away into something completely unstable, in the wake of subprime mortgages and derivatives that were sold between banks that also held onto savings… at least for a short while they held onto savings… until those banks started collapsing. Moralizing about banks or homeowners or bailouts won't bring that liberty back. Even if your money wasn't in those banks that doesn't mean you get to escape the economic collapse that follows. It doesn't mean that your property is protected. Your fist can't bring injury upon their faces without legal consequence, but the diseases your neighbor acquires after they lose their job and health benefits could kill you. The law won't protect you against that, your health and the value of your property aren't protected. Poverty has many meanings besides the economic one, and all of them are relevant. We have watched as our freedoms have been brought closer to destruction, after a failure to recognize their global reality. "If you do not share your wealth with the poor, they will share their poverty." The reality of that cannot be moralized away by appeals to personal accountability. If a poverty of democracy allows a people to become disenfranchised, and if poverty allows education to become a scarce resource then it affects my liberty. If poverty in other countries leads to poor sewage and limits access to clean water, if poverty allows disease to spread, if poverty allows these places to collapse further into economic failure and the inevitable failure of the state that follows, and that poverty allows terrorism to find a better audience then it affects my liberty. If poverty allows for environmental devastation, and nuclear or chemical waste that pollutes our environment then it affects my liberty. If poverty shows up at the emergency ward and can't pay, If poverty provides no shelter for them or for us from them then it affects my liberty. If poverty allows for the whole globe to fall into economic collapse or international wars like we saw in the last century, as they play out in a world where distances between places are growing smaller…what remains of the freedom that our liberties were meant to protect. If each of us as individuals ignore the impoverished areas of the world, and here at home, we place all of our liberties and their ability to function within jeopardy. Yes I am a libertarian who has been mugged by reality. Pragmatism demands that I understand that my liberties are inextricably bound to those around me, rather than appealing to ideas about personal accountability as if such legal distinctions could protect my liberties in any functional meaningful way.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)